When using an ATM, it’s easy to assume that all transactions follow the same pattern. However, John notices something odd: he has made two ATM transactions, but only one has a fee. Why does this happen? The answer lies in how banking networks, ATM policies, and Interac fees work. Let’s dive deeper into this mystery and uncover the reasons behind this discrepancy.
Biography Table for “john has two atm transactions but only one of them has a fee (interac). why?
Category | Details |
---|---|
Title | John Has Two ATM Transactions But Only One of Them Has a Fee (Interac). Why? |
Topic | ATM transactions, banking fees, Interac network, surcharge fees |
Main Question | Why was John charged a fee on only one of his two ATM transactions? |
Primary Cause | One transaction was at an in-network ATM (fee-free), while the other was at an out-of-network ATM (charged a fee) |
Banking System Involved | Canadian banking system, Interac debit network |
Possible Factors | ATM ownership, surcharge fees, account type, bank reimbursement policies |
Best Solutions | Use in-network ATMs, check fee notifications, withdraw larger amounts at once, choose banks that refund ATM fees |
Target Audience | Bank customers, ATM users, financial advisors, Canadians using Interac |
Relevance | Helps users understand ATM fee policies and how to avoid unnecessary charges |
Engagement Level | High, as many users face unexpected ATM fees and seek solutions |
Category | Details |
Understanding Interac and ATM Networks
Before we analyze why John is facing a fee on only one transaction, it’s essential to understand what Interac is and how ATM networks operate.
- Interac Network: Interac is a widely used Canadian debit network that connects banks and credit unions, allowing customers to perform transactions at ATMs and make payments.
- In-Network vs. Out-of-Network ATMs: ATMs are typically categorized as either part of your bank’s network or outside of it. This distinction is critical in determining whether a fee applies.
When John uses an ATM from his bank’s network, there is typically no extra fee because his bank absorbs the cost. However, when he uses an ATM outside his bank’s network, the ATM owner or the Interac network usually imposes a surcharge fee.
Why Does John Have a Fee on One Transaction But Not the Other?
Now that we understand how ATM networks work, let’s break down why John’s two transactions resulted in different fees:
One ATM Was In-Network, and the Other Was Out-of-Network
This is the most likely explanation. John may have used one ATM that belonged to his bank and another ATM operated by a different bank or a private ATM provider.
- No Fee Transaction: The transaction was free if John used an ATM within his bank’s network.
- Transaction with a Fee: If John used an out-of-network ATM, the owner of that ATM charged a fee.
The ATM Owner Charged a Surcharge Fee
Even within the Interac network, some ATMs impose extra fees depending on who owns them. Some privately owned ATMs, often found in gas stations, convenience stores, and shopping centers, charge higher withdrawal fees.
- Example: It was likely fee-free if John used a major bank’s ATM for his first transaction.
- A surcharge fee might have been added if he withdrew cash from a convenience store’s ATM.
Bank Policies on Reimbursement of Fees
Certain banks refund out-of-network ATM fees as part of premium account packages. If John has a premium banking plan, he might be eligible for a fee reimbursement on one of his transactions, making it appear that only one transaction was charged.
- Some banks reimburse a set number of fees per month.
- If John’s first transaction qualified for a refund and the second did not, he would only see one fee on his statement.
Interac-Specific Fees and Rules
Interac charges a fee for transactions outside of a bank’s ATM network. If John had used an ATM that did not directly connect to his bank but operated via Interac, he may have been subject to a network fee.
- Some banks absorb these fees for their customers.
- Depending on account type and policies, others pass the fee on to the user.
Different Transaction Types and Their Fees
Not all ATM transactions are treated equally. Some banks charge for specific actions beyond cash withdrawals.
- Balance Inquiries: Some ATMs charge a fee to check your balance.
- Transfers Between Accounts: If John transferred funds at an out-of-network ATM, an extra charge could have been applied.
- Cash Withdrawals: Some ATMs charge a higher fee for withdrawing more significant amounts.

How to Avoid ATM Fees in the Future
Understanding why John was charged a fee on only one transaction can help others avoid unnecessary ATM fees. Here are some tips to minimize ATM costs:
Use In-Network ATMs
Always try to use your bank’s ATMs whenever possible. Many banks offer ATM locators on their websites or mobile apps to help customers find nearby fee-free ATMs.
Check Fee Notifications Before Withdrawing
ATMs usually display a message on the screen stating whether a fee will be charged. Always read this message carefully before confirming the transaction.
Use Cash-Back Options at Retailers
Many grocery stores and retailers offer a cash-back option when you purchase using your debit card. This can be a good way to get cash without paying an ATM fee.
Choose a Bank That Refunds ATM Fees
Some banks and credit unions offer ATM fee reimbursements as part of premium accounts. Switching to a bank that provides this benefit may be worth it if you frequently withdraw cash.
Withdraw Larger Amounts Less Frequently
If you must use an ATM with a fee, withdrawing a more significant amount in one transaction can help reduce the frequency of fees.
Use Digital Banking Options
With the rise of e-transfers and mobile banking, carrying cash is becoming less necessary. Using Interac e-Transfers or mobile payment options can help avoid ATM fees altogether.

Last Review
In summary, john has two atm transactions but only one of them has a fee (interac). why?, which is most likely due to differences in ATM ownership, network policies, and bank-specific rules. If one transaction was performed at an in-network ATM and the other at an out-of-network machine, the latter would incur a fee. Other factors, such as surcharge fees, Interac network charges, and bank reimbursements, can also play a role in why one transaction had a fee while the other did not.
By understanding how ATM fees work and using strategies to avoid them, John—and anyone else—can save money on unnecessary charges. Always check ATM fee policies and use your bank’s tools to find the best options for free transactions!
Comments 1